PkHonor

Thearlygamer wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 3:33 pm i also didn't like the multitude of phat/santa ideas btw

I think youre shotgunning way too much info for a single post with hardly any info in the actual body of this post, albiet the voting seems pretty straight forward i still think this should be explained in detail on the post, preferrably in bullet points that are direct to the point rather than (for lack of better terms) a lot of yapping around it.

Also, i dont see a counter "no" option for - Yes to perm unlocks to acc that increase pkp points at a small %

I think a "vote boss" just doesnt make sense, voting is for the server and its just some side content, i dont see why a "boss" would be needed for this? If you want to add a custom boss do it for something else imo, but dont let it impact voting in whatever way you're thinking it could

Also no real reason to have a yes/no to all at the bottom when theres yes/no's to most of the options

I think the vote store could definitely use a revamp, especially for ironmen, but this aint it

Will be ok2 wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 2:10 pm Good work with revisions & taking community feedback in a constructive manner.

I personally think pots/runes in PKP shop is a great sink/idea.

Not a big fan of tons of cosmetics being added via donator / vote would like to see that kept to a minimum. I’ll keep my opinion about 1-2 high valued point items being added to vote shop. Maybe something like black Santa hat 10K vote points & gold party hat 25K vote points (both tradable). Make them in collection log too) to really get Jayden & Niels heart rate up.

Pk’ing is easily abusable so any rewards / scrolls I think would be a net negative. I believe some individuals might take advantage of the rewards by boosting it while having minimal staff around to spend time investigating it. Not worth it IMO for risk/reward factor.these scrolls could be a neat addition to the LMS shop though.

Throw the cannon as a set maybe?

Ktm drip wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 8:02 pm I disagree with the whole idea of voting been side content I think voting is the most important part of the game as it’s the main source of advertisement.

I’m just after potential ideas to do some shops are very lack luster and trying to find things I could do to help make some stores more up to date with current content. Pkp points are pretty useless and I think voting outside of lucky pets is pretty pointless.

If you think the for Ironman vote store needs revamping. Why does it? What would be some good ideas to put inside the store instead of just saying but this ain’t that.

Tom061202 wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 11:44 pm I will be blatantly honest, don't take it as if I am being just rude for the sake of being rude.

I think I'm speaking for most of OG PkHonor players when I say this: Your previous post and this one are very very very scary and alarming. I really don't think most of us want PkHonor to turn into another cheap, funky, arcady type of RSPS like all the others.

I like some of the content you have suggested, but you always seem to "fuck it up" with funky ideas from another server. Also, please proof read your suggestions before posting them. They are incredibly hard to read, painfully hard even, and very often are we left guessing what you mean and how you see the content you're putting forth and suggestion. Also, make sure those are just that, suggestions.

Not making a poll FIRST about the BASIC ideas was your mistake. You do that and THEN take inputs and conversations from the reply section to COME UP with a good way to implement them the way people like, if they like it at all.

I think we all kind of feel cheated by not being asked in the first place. What makes PKH a community server is the exact fact that the forums replies make up the update specifics after someone suggested a BASIC idea without any specifics...

Instead of making a suggestion post/poll about BASIC, premature ideas, you made a post about things you've already "decided" to add to PKH on your own accord to then ask the community what's wrong about it... That usually only means chaos in the reply section. It's like you're trying to change a game we've loved for almost 2 decades into a chaotic server like all the others...

To round up that topic, I'll speak for me, but why I like about this server is that there is as little "funky", "arcady" made-up items/content as possible. It feels serious, not arcady and it follows OSRS somewhat tightly with LIGHT customization that doesn't break the whole feel of OSRS, while offering us nice QOL features that a private server should have to make it "easier" or more accessible. I don't know for others, but I like the fact that the only custom thing on PKH is the whips and the way they are used which is unique to this server. To me it's enough! I want to play a game that resembles OSRS, not a completely different MMORPG.

Now for the "suggestions" you made:

I'm all for hard mode TOB... But funky weapon upgrades just make it sound like there's going to be way too many useless weapons in the future if OSRS bosses get added and we get other, not made-up weapons from the actual game (TOA weaps, Venator bow, Voidwaker...). I am also worried the upgraded Scythe would make PkHonor into EzHonor else where than HMT and be way too OP. But, if you are to add those upgrades anyway without really caring about what the community wants, I think the 10 prayer pts gain every 2 tic for example would be quite OP. A player would gain back 80 prayer points during that 10 seconds.

I'm all for the well of good fortune that acts as a money sink and provides us with "rare" events we'd really like to have more of like cons, prayer, hunter and agi for skilling or "end game" bosses and raids for PVM.

I'm all for Daily/Weekly tasks so that there's a way for us to be guided into our playing session if we're bored and don't really know what we want to do while getting rewarded for it in a reasonable matter (not too high of rewards for it not to be completely abused).

All for added clue rewards faithful to those in OSRS.

As for vote and donator shop updates, I'm all for updating them since they have needed a change for a while now. The TEMPORARY scrolls you suggested that have a timer, I agree with if they are fairly valued, same with the slayer skip one. Those sound like reasonable little add-ons if balanced properly. I don't disagree with adding more cosmetics like partyhats and santa hats to Dono/Vote shops. However, I see a little bit of a problem personally in making the gold partyhat a neitz faceguard. First of all, if that were to be the case, hopefully we'd need to add a jaw to the partyhat and not just get the BIS STR bonus helm by voting/donating. Second of all, I believe that faceguard is a bit random for gold... Dragon partyhat = Dragon Full Helm stats make sense, same with Barrows partyhat = Guthan's helm stats. But, I think the Barrows partyhat should be the last, most expensive variant. What would make sense for the Gold partyhat is that it should have Rune full helm stats like the Gilded full helm in my opinion, hence placing it under Barrows and Dragon partyhats in value and stats.

Now about the Whip on consistency. I am not as scared of that custom update as it's only continuing an exsting customization of PkHonor. However, I have to say that I don't see a way it can be brought in and serve a true purpose. It's either going to be dead content or incredibly OP. Why? Because say you want to be the Consistency/Unholy whip-cape combo to be as effective, you'd have to make the new whip's accuracy super high with still a good amount of STR bonus for it to rival with the Souls/Chaos or Unholy/Chaos combos that already exist as custom whip meta. But, if you do that, then Imagine how WAY overpowered would be a Consistency/Chaos combo with the attack speed of Chaos...! So, I'm all for adding a new whip if it does serve a purpose that doesn't get too OP in another combo, but that sounds hard to implement properly without making it EzHonor, once again.

All for adding a way to spend PkHonor Points to buy useful stuff in the PKH shop. However, I think your PKHP mystery box is dead content before it's even release because of the items you have suggested to put in it... It's all items we don't use as soon as we go over 100hrs played if I'm being honest. Also, since you mentionned it in this latest poll, Supplies/overloads/prayer/pots/runes in PkHonor shop is a big NO from me... It takes away from the fact that during early game you might want to make money making potions, runes or any useful supplies for people. Also, most these things we already get loads of as drops doing varied PVMing activities.

Anyway, to end with my personal opinion, I think most of us want good OSRS content that we don't have yet along with nice, simple QOL updates that don't change the essence of the game and turn it into and arcade RSPS and, no offense, but alot of your suggestions are just that.

Tom061202 wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 11:44 pm I will be blatantly honest, don't take it as if I am being just rude for the sake of being rude.

I think I'm speaking for most of OG PkHonor players when I say this: Your previous post and this one are very very very scary and alarming. I really don't think most of us want PkHonor to turn into another cheap, funky, arcady type of RSPS like all the others.

I like some of the content you have suggested, but you always seem to "fuck it up" with funky ideas from another server. Also, please proof read your suggestions before posting them. They are incredibly hard to read, painfully hard even, and very often are we left guessing what you mean and how you see the content you're putting forth and suggestion. Also, make sure those are just that, suggestions.

Not making a poll FIRST about the BASIC ideas was your mistake. You do that and THEN take inputs and conversations from the reply section to COME UP with a good way to implement them the way people like, if they like it at all.

I think we all kind of feel cheated by not being asked in the first place. What makes PKH a community server is the exact fact that the forums replies make up the update specifics after someone suggested a BASIC idea without any specifics...

Instead of making a suggestion post/poll about BASIC, premature ideas, you made a post about things you've already "decided" to add to PKH on your own accord to then ask the community what's wrong about it... That usually only means chaos in the reply section. It's like you're trying to change a game we've loved for almost 2 decades into a chaotic server like all the others...

To round up that topic, I'll speak for me, but why I like about this server is that there is as little "funky", "arcady" made-up items/content as possible. It feels serious, not arcady and it follows OSRS somewhat tightly with LIGHT customization that doesn't break the whole feel of OSRS, while offering us nice QOL features that a private server should have to make it "easier" or more accessible. I don't know for others, but I like the fact that the only custom thing on PKH is the whips and the way they are used which is unique to this server. To me it's enough! I want to play a game that resembles OSRS, not a completely different MMORPG.

Now for the "suggestions" you made:

I'm all for hard mode TOB... But funky weapon upgrades just make it sound like there's going to be way too many useless weapons in the future if OSRS bosses get added and we get other, not made-up weapons from the actual game (TOA weaps, Venator bow, Voidwaker...). I am also worried the upgraded Scythe would make PkHonor into EzHonor else where than HMT and be way too OP. But, if you are to add those upgrades anyway without really caring about what the community wants, I think the 10 prayer pts gain every 2 tic for example would be quite OP. A player would gain back 80 prayer points during that 10 seconds.

I'm all for the well of good fortune that acts as a money sink and provides us with "rare" events we'd really like to have more of like cons, prayer, hunter and agi for skilling or "end game" bosses and raids for PVM.

I'm all for Daily/Weekly tasks so that there's a way for us to be guided into our playing session if we're bored and don't really know what we want to do while getting rewarded for it in a reasonable matter (not too high of rewards for it not to be completely abused).

All for added clue rewards faithful to those in OSRS.

As for vote and donator shop updates, I'm all for updating them since they have needed a change for a while now. The TEMPORARY scrolls you suggested that have a timer, I agree with if they are fairly valued, same with the slayer skip one. Those sound like reasonable little add-ons if balanced properly. I don't disagree with adding more cosmetics like partyhats and santa hats to Dono/Vote shops. However, I see a little bit of a problem personally in making the gold partyhat a neitz faceguard. First of all, if that were to be the case, hopefully we'd need to add a jaw to the partyhat and not just get the BIS STR bonus helm by voting/donating. Second of all, I believe that faceguard is a bit random for gold... Dragon partyhat = Dragon Full Helm stats make sense, same with Barrows partyhat = Guthan's helm stats. But, I think the Barrows partyhat should be the last, most expensive variant. What would make sense for the Gold partyhat is that it should have Rune full helm stats like the Gilded full helm in my opinion, hence placing it under Barrows and Dragon partyhats in value and stats.

Now about the Whip on consistency. I am not as scared of that custom update as it's only continuing an exsting customization of PkHonor. However, I have to say that I don't see a way it can be brought in and serve a true purpose. It's either going to be dead content or incredibly OP. Why? Because say you want to be the Consistency/Unholy whip-cape combo to be as effective, you'd have to make the new whip's accuracy super high with still a good amount of STR bonus for it to rival with the Souls/Chaos or Unholy/Chaos combos that already exist as custom whip meta. But, if you do that, then Imagine how WAY overpowered would be a Consistency/Chaos combo with the attack speed of Chaos...! So, I'm all for adding a new whip if it does serve a purpose that doesn't get too OP in another combo, but that sounds hard to implement properly without making it EzHonor, once again.

All for adding a way to spend PkHonor Points to buy useful stuff in the PKH shop. However, I think your PKHP mystery box is dead content before it's even release because of the items you have suggested to put in it... It's all items we don't use as soon as we go over 100hrs played if I'm being honest. Also, since you mentionned it in this latest poll, Supplies/overloads/prayer/pots/runes in PkHonor shop is a big NO from me... It takes away from the fact that during early game you might want to make money making potions, runes or any useful supplies for people. Also, most these things we already get loads of as drops doing varied PVMing activities.

Anyway, to end with my personal opinion, I think most of us want good OSRS content that we don't have yet along with nice, simple QOL updates that don't change the essence of the game and turn it into and arcade RSPS and, no offense, but alot of your suggestions are just that.

Will wrote: Sat Aug 08, 2026 1:10 am

Tom061202 wrote: Fri Aug 07, 2026 11:44 pm I will be blatantly honest, don't take it as if I am being just rude for the sake of being rude.

I think I'm speaking for most of OG PkHonor players when I say this: Your previous post and this one are very very very scary and alarming. I really don't think most of us want PkHonor to turn into another cheap, funky, arcady type of RSPS like all the others.

I like some of the content you have suggested, but you always seem to "fuck it up" with funky ideas from another server. Also, please proof read your suggestions before posting them. They are incredibly hard to read, painfully hard even, and very often are we left guessing what you mean and how you see the content you're putting forth and suggestion. Also, make sure those are just that, suggestions.

Not making a poll FIRST about the BASIC ideas was your mistake. You do that and THEN take inputs and conversations from the reply section to COME UP with a good way to implement them the way people like, if they like it at all.

I think we all kind of feel cheated by not being asked in the first place. What makes PKH a community server is the exact fact that the forums replies make up the update specifics after someone suggested a BASIC idea without any specifics...

Instead of making a suggestion post/poll about BASIC, premature ideas, you made a post about things you've already "decided" to add to PKH on your own accord to then ask the community what's wrong about it... That usually only means chaos in the reply section. It's like you're trying to change a game we've loved for almost 2 decades into a chaotic server like all the others...

To round up that topic, I'll speak for me, but why I like about this server is that there is as little "funky", "arcady" made-up items/content as possible. It feels serious, not arcady and it follows OSRS somewhat tightly with LIGHT customization that doesn't break the whole feel of OSRS, while offering us nice QOL features that a private server should have to make it "easier" or more accessible. I don't know for others, but I like the fact that the only custom thing on PKH is the whips and the way they are used which is unique to this server. To me it's enough! I want to play a game that resembles OSRS, not a completely different MMORPG.

Now for the "suggestions" you made:

I'm all for hard mode TOB... But funky weapon upgrades just make it sound like there's going to be way too many useless weapons in the future if OSRS bosses get added and we get other, not made-up weapons from the actual game (TOA weaps, Venator bow, Voidwaker...). I am also worried the upgraded Scythe would make PkHonor into EzHonor else where than HMT and be way too OP. But, if you are to add those upgrades anyway without really caring about what the community wants, I think the 10 prayer pts gain every 2 tic for example would be quite OP. A player would gain back 80 prayer points during that 10 seconds.

I'm all for the well of good fortune that acts as a money sink and provides us with "rare" events we'd really like to have more of like cons, prayer, hunter and agi for skilling or "end game" bosses and raids for PVM.

I'm all for Daily/Weekly tasks so that there's a way for us to be guided into our playing session if we're bored and don't really know what we want to do while getting rewarded for it in a reasonable matter (not too high of rewards for it not to be completely abused).

All for added clue rewards faithful to those in OSRS.

As for vote and donator shop updates, I'm all for updating them since they have needed a change for a while now. The TEMPORARY scrolls you suggested that have a timer, I agree with if they are fairly valued, same with the slayer skip one. Those sound like reasonable little add-ons if balanced properly. I don't disagree with adding more cosmetics like partyhats and santa hats to Dono/Vote shops. However, I see a little bit of a problem personally in making the gold partyhat a neitz faceguard. First of all, if that were to be the case, hopefully we'd need to add a jaw to the partyhat and not just get the BIS STR bonus helm by voting/donating. Second of all, I believe that faceguard is a bit random for gold... Dragon partyhat = Dragon Full Helm stats make sense, same with Barrows partyhat = Guthan's helm stats. But, I think the Barrows partyhat should be the last, most expensive variant. What would make sense for the Gold partyhat is that it should have Rune full helm stats like the Gilded full helm in my opinion, hence placing it under Barrows and Dragon partyhats in value and stats.

Now about the Whip on consistency. I am not as scared of that custom update as it's only continuing an exsting customization of PkHonor. However, I have to say that I don't see a way it can be brought in and serve a true purpose. It's either going to be dead content or incredibly OP. Why? Because say you want to be the Consistency/Unholy whip-cape combo to be as effective, you'd have to make the new whip's accuracy super high with still a good amount of STR bonus for it to rival with the Souls/Chaos or Unholy/Chaos combos that already exist as custom whip meta. But, if you do that, then Imagine how WAY overpowered would be a Consistency/Chaos combo with the attack speed of Chaos...! So, I'm all for adding a new whip if it does serve a purpose that doesn't get too OP in another combo, but that sounds hard to implement properly without making it EzHonor, once again.

All for adding a way to spend PkHonor Points to buy useful stuff in the PKH shop. However, I think your PKHP mystery box is dead content before it's even release because of the items you have suggested to put in it... It's all items we don't use as soon as we go over 100hrs played if I'm being honest. Also, since you mentionned it in this latest poll, Supplies/overloads/prayer/pots/runes in PkHonor shop is a big NO from me... It takes away from the fact that during early game you might want to make money making potions, runes or any useful supplies for people. Also, most these things we already get loads of as drops doing varied PVMing activities.

Anyway, to end with my personal opinion, I think most of us want good OSRS content that we don't have yet along with nice, simple QOL updates that don't change the essence of the game and turn it into and arcade RSPS and, no offense, but alot of your suggestions are just that.

+1 to all of this. Couldn't have said it better myself.

Polling so many different ideas at the same time, with relatively little detail on how each one would actually affect the game, makes it difficult for the community to properly evaluate any of them. As I said in my other post, I don't think this community is particularly receptive to major changes unless the content is well thought out, carefully balanced, and discussed beforehand.

I also don't see how throwing all of these changes at the game simultaneously is going to increase the player base. If anything, I think introducing this many changes at once could drive more players away, particularly if they feel like the game they have played for years is suddenly changing too much.

I'd recommend starting with something relatively small, such as the Well of Good Fortune, and seeing how the community responds. From there, you can move on to the next idea. This gives a larger portion of the player base time to experience the content, provide feedback, and have a meaningful discussion about what works and what doesn't before something else is introduced.

I think PKH needs consistency in its updates more than it needs one massive update that attempts to change several aspects of the game at once. A lot of these proposed changes could have a significant impact on the current meta, economy, progression, and overall feel of the server. That's not necessarily a bad thing by itself, but trying to implement all of them together makes it much harder to identify what is actually helping or hurting the game.

Small, consistent updates that are properly discussed and balanced are much more likely to work in the long run than one huge update that completely changes the meta of the game. Give the community time to adapt to and evaluate one change before introducing another. I think that approach would be much healthier for PKH.